After putting the Caraway cookware set to the test over the course of a year, I’m excited to share my honest review with you. My goal is to provide an unbiased account of this luxury brand’s reputation and performance. You might be wondering if Caraway is worth the investment, especially considering the price point for nonstick pans. The answer lies in the quality and functionality of their products.
In this review, I’ll dive into the details that matter most: aesthetics, quality and durability, cooking performance, and care and maintenance. As a regular home-cooking mom of two, I’ve had the opportunity to put these pots and pans through their paces. And while I was not compensated for this review, my intention is to provide an honest assessment of Caraway’s products.
So, if you’re considering investing in this luxury cookware brand, keep reading for my thoughts on whether it lives up to the hype.
What’s So Special About Caraway Cookware?
Caraway’s reputation is built upon two significant aspects: its vibrant, Instagram-worthy cookware collection and its commitment to non-toxic ceramic coating. This innovative approach ensures the pans are not only aesthetically pleasing but also free from toxic chemicals commonly associated with Teflon-coated pots and pans.
As a home cook myself, I understand the importance of having reliable non-stick pans in the kitchen.
From crafting the perfect omelet to cooking a variety of dishes, these pans make life easier. Caraway’s eco-friendly alternative is particularly appealing, as it offers a healthier option for those who prioritize their well-being.
While Caraway offers an array of products, including bakeware sets, this review focuses solely on its pots and pans. As someone who has been cooking with my All-Clad set for years, I was initially skeptical about the legitimacy and value of Caraway’s cookware.
However, after using it, I can confidently say that I’m a fan.
In the following review, I’ll share my honest assessment of Caraway’s cookware set, highlighting both the pros and cons to help readers make an informed decision.
Caraway Has Nailed Aesthetics
Caraway has successfully transformed everyday cookware into a desirable possession. Who would have thought that something as mundane as pots and pans could become so alluring? The brand’s creations are now presented in vibrant, playful colors and sleek, high-end designs, making them perfect for showcasing one’s personality in the kitchen.
While they may not be an absolute necessity, the unique charm of these cookware pieces has inspired me to display mine proudly, rather than stashing them away in a cabinet. The ease of access and ability to decorate my kitchen with such visually appealing items are definite bonuses.
Quality and Durability
After putting my Caraway cookware to the test for more than a year, I’m thrilled to report that it has withstood the rigors of daily use without showing any signs of wear and tear. The ceramic coating, free from harmful PFAS and heavy metals, has proven to be both non-toxic and remarkably durable.
While the initial heat resistance of up to 550 degrees may have raised some concerns about its longevity, I’m pleased to say that my Caraway set continues to perform flawlessly, just as it did when I first received it.
Cooking Performance
The ease of cooking with Caraway cookware is undeniable. Initially, I was dubious about its performance, likening it to ‘cookware for beginners.’ However, my skepticism was quickly dispelled as I discovered the benefits of using this set. The nonstick surface makes food release effortless, eliminating the need for scrubbing and reducing cooking time. The even heat distribution allows for consistent results, and the low-maintenance cleaning process is a game-changer.
Furthermore, Caraway cookware requires significantly less oil compared to stainless steel alternatives, making it an ideal choice for those seeking healthier meal options. While some may find the recommended temperature range (low to medium heat) limiting, I believe this minor drawback is outweighed by the numerous advantages of using these pans. With proper care, cooking with Caraway cookware can be a truly enjoyable experience.
Caraway Cookware Maintenance and Cleaning
The Caraway cookware set’s aesthetics are undoubtedly its most appealing feature. However, the reality is that these pans are high-maintenance and require a great deal of TLC to maintain their original appearance. As someone who values ease and efficiency in their daily routine, I was initially hesitant to recommend this set due to its propensity for scratches and stains. The bottom of the pan, in particular, seems to scratch easily, which can be frustrating to deal with.
While it’s true that Barkeeper’s Friend and a soft sponge can help clean up any messes, it’s not exactly the most convenient solution. Moreover, the recommended hand washing method may not align with the busy lifestyle of many households. However, I did learn from a fellow Caraway user that it’s possible to wash these pans in the dishwasher without compromising their integrity.
Once I got past my initial reservations and started using them more frequently, I found that they performed well enough despite the maintenance requirements. Ultimately, the Caraway cookware set is not without its drawbacks, but it does offer some redeeming qualities. Its performance is still satisfactory, even if its appearance doesn’t quite live up to expectations.
Daily Cooking with Caraway
While non-stick pans excel in cooking certain foods, they’re not ideal for achieving a perfect sear on a steak or other proteins that require high heat. It’s not the pan’s fault; its design is geared towards preventing sticking and making food release easy, rather than caramelization. Don’t expect your non-stick collection to be all-encompassing; even their enthusiasts acknowledge the need for a diverse range of cookware in their kitchen arsenal.
For me, these pans remain staples, but I recognize the value of having other options like stainless steel or cast iron at my disposal.
The Worst Parts of Caraway Cookware
While it’s essential to highlight the positives about Caraway cookware, it’s also crucial to discuss some of its limitations. One of the most significant drawbacks is the relatively high price point of non-stick pans. To put this into perspective, a full set of All-Clad cookware, which I’ve owned for over 10 years and still looks like new, costs $899.
In contrast, Caraway’s full set costs $595, which may not be justified by the average lifespan of ceramic cookware, ranging from one to three years. Another significant con is that Caraway cookware requires more maintenance than expected. Despite taking great care to hand wash them, I’ve noticed chips and scratches on my white pans, which are disappointing given their premium price tag. Moreover, metal utensils should be avoided, as well as high-heat cooking, to prevent damage.
Additionally, the gold stainless steel handles can get extremely hot when cooking, so it’s essential to exercise caution. In summary, Caraway cookware demands careful handling and maintenance to ensure its longevity. This includes using oven mitts, silicone utensils, and a non-abrasive sponge to clean them. While they may have some aesthetic appeal, the high price point and required maintenance might not justify the investment for some users.
Is Caraway Cookware Worth It?
As I reflected on my conversation with a friend about my Caraway cookware set, I realized that my initial assessment had changed significantly over time. Initially, I hadn’t been entirely convinced that I loved the pans, but as the weeks went by, I found myself reaching for them every day. This was despite having owned and cooking with my All-Clad set since 2012 – a collection I swear by. The difference?
Caraway pans have become ridiculously easy to use and maintain, thanks to their dishwasher-safe design. Gone are the days of obsessively cleaning and maintaining them; instead, I can simply pop them in the dishwasher and get on with my day. In fact, I’ve found myself cooking with my Caraway set nearly every single day – a testament to just how much I’ve come to appreciate the convenience they offer.
Despite my initial reservations about nonstick pans being inferior to stainless steel, I’ve come to realize that there’s definitely a place for them in our kitchens, particularly for busy home chefs like myself.
What Caraway Bundle is Best?
While the Deluxe Cookware set is an excellent choice, I’d recommend prioritizing the frying pan or sauté pan if your budget only allows for one additional piece beyond stainless steel and cast iron. These pans are incredibly versatile and can be used daily. The Sauté pan, in particular, has become a staple in my kitchen. You can get away with owning just this pan and/or a few frying pans, as you don’t necessarily need a nonstick pot to boil pasta or cook rice.
In fact, a pressure cooker is often better suited for cooking grains like rice. On the other hand, investing in three pans still leaves you out $330 short of the complete set. Considering the additional cost, it’s not much more to go all-in on the Deluxe set and enjoy the benefits of magnetic pan racks, a canvas lid holder, and organized storage inside your cabinet. These thoughtful touches are what make this set truly special.
Caraway Cookware Coupon Codes & Where to Buy
You can purchase Caraway Cookware directly from their website, where they occasionally run promotions. To stay informed about these deals, sign up for my mailing list and I’ll be sure to alert you! You can also find Caraway Cookware on Amazon and in-store at Target. For a touch of elegance, look out for the special edition colors exclusively available at Crate & Barrel. Keep an eye out for their Prime Day discount, which typically offers 15-20% off.
Caraway Reddit Reviews
Caraway Cookware’s Reddit reviews are a testament to the brand’s versatility and durability, despite some users’ lukewarm opinions. While some owners dismiss their pans as ‘absolute garbage’, others swear by them for specific tasks. My personal experience with the cookware has been overwhelmingly positive – I’ve used mine for at least a year without any significant issues. In fact, I’m so pleased that I’d consider repurchasing my favorite sauté pan if it ever needed to be replaced.
That being said, I wouldn’t necessarily opt for the entire set again, as it’s not something I use frequently or feel is worth the investment. A common criticism of Caraway Cookware is its fragility and tendency to chip. While this may be a concern for some, the brand does offer guidance on how to properly care for their pans to extend their lifespan. As someone who’s familiar with high-quality ceramic cookware, I’m not expecting Caraway’s products to last as long as my trusty All-Clad pans.
However, based on what I’ve read, it appears that this level of durability may be typical for ceramic cookware in general.
Caraway Cookware Dupes
For those who have made it through this point and are eager to give Caraway Cookware a go, but are hesitant due to the cost, there are some affordable alternatives worth considering. To make high-quality cookware more accessible, I’ve curated a list of dupes that mimic the performance of Caraway without breaking the bank.
Sam’s Club Member’s Mark 11-Piece Cookware Set
While it may not be an exact replica, this cookware set is an affordable alternative to Caraway’s offering. Priced under $160 for an 11-piece set, it’s a compelling option for home cooks and professionals alike. The variety of colorways is impressive, with 12 options available, many of which mirror the aesthetic of Caraway’s signature gold-handled pieces.
Moreover, the reviews from satisfied customers are overwhelmingly positive, making this dupe a great value for those looking to upgrade their cookware arsenal.
BUY HERE
Beautiful by Drew Barrymore 12pc Ceramic Non-stick Cookware Set
Walmart’s Beautiful by Drew Barrymore ceramic cookware set boasts a stunning array of pieces within its 12-piece collection. Available in four vibrant colorways and adorned with gold handles, this set not only looks impressive but also includes practical trivets for effortless food presentation. With a stellar 4.3-star rating based on customer reviews, it’s clear that this ceramic cookware has won over many hearts – and kitchens.
BUY HERE
For those who have had the chance to use Caraway Cookware, we’d love to hear about their hands-on encounter. How did the cookware perform in terms of cooking efficiency, durability, and overall satisfaction?